In Loving Memory: Honoring the life and legacy of our esteemed partner, Lawrence ‘Larry’ Scaringelli
Visual guide showing what to expect at probate mediation, helping families understand and resolve estate disputes peacefully in Arizona.

Losing a loved one is painful. When legal disputes arise over their estate, the stress can feel overwhelming. Many families in Arizona choose mediation to resolve probate issues without going through a lengthy trial. 

If you are wondering what to expect at probate mediation, you are not alone. Mediation offers families a way to address conflicts with guidance, fairness, and privacy. It also saves time, money, and emotional strain. Here’s what you need to know before walking into probate mediation.

What Is Probate Mediation?

Probate is the legal process of settling a person’s estate after death. It includes managing their debts and distributing their assets under court supervision.

Probate mediation is a structured process in which family members and other interested parties meet with a neutral mediator to resolve disagreements about an estate. Instead of battling in court, the parties sit down in a confidential setting to share their concerns and try to find a resolution.

Unlike a judge, the mediator does not make decisions. Instead, they help participants communicate, clarify misunderstandings, and explore possible solutions.

Why Do Families Choose Mediation in Probate Disputes?

Families often choose mediation because court trials are expensive, public, and emotionally draining. Mediation gives people more control over the outcome and allows for creative solutions that a court might be unable to provide.

Common reasons people enter mediation include:

  • Disagreements over how to interpret a will or trust,
  • Questions over the validity of a will;
  • Concerns about the actions of a personal representative or trustee; and
  • Family conflicts over property distribution or inheritance.

These issues are difficult to face, especially while grieving. Mediation can provide a healthy path forward by protecting relationships while resolving legal concerns.

What Are the Benefits of Probate Mediation?

Mediation provides several advantages over going to trial, including:

  • Privacy. The discussions remain confidential and out of the public record.
  • Cost savings. Legal fees and court costs are typically lower than those of litigation.
  • Time efficiency. Cases often resolve more quickly than if they went to trial. 
  • Preserving relationships. Mediation reduces hostility and allows families to move forward.
  • More control over the outcome. Parties can reach tailored agreements that fit their family’s needs instead of having a judge decide.

Mediation eases conflict and empowers loved ones to shape solutions a court might never provide.

What Happens Before Probate Mediation?

Before mediation, each party should prepare by:

  • Gathering and reviewing estate planning documents, financial statements, and relevant court filings;
  • Considering personal goals and what outcomes would be acceptable; and
  • Talking with an attorney about likely issues and possible compromises.

Preparation ensures everyone is ready to engage in meaningful mediation discussions. You should also be ready to compromise, communicate with compassion, and have a problem-solving mindset. Mediation works best when participants focus on solutions rather than conflict. 

What to Expect at Probate Mediation in Arizona

The process aims to be less intimidating than court, but it still follows a structured path. Here is what to expect:

  • Introduction by the mediator. The mediator will explain the process, set ground rules, and stress the importance of respectful communication.
  • Opening statements from each side. Each party will have a chance to share its perspective without interruption.
  • Joint discussions. The mediator may guide a conversation with everyone present to identify issues and areas of agreement.
  • Private sessions. The mediator may meet privately with each party to explore settlement options and encourage compromise.
  • Negotiation and resolution. If the parties reach an agreement, it will be written down and, in most cases, submitted to the court for approval.

The mediator’s role is not to take sides. Mediators are impartial facilitators who help participants reach a solution that works for everyone.

Do You Need an Attorney for Probate Mediation?

You are not legally required to have an attorney for mediation of probate disputes, but having one can be very helpful. An attorney can help you with:

  • Explaining your rights and options under Arizona law;
  • Gathering documents, clarifying goals, and planning negotiation strategies;
  • Ensuring proposed agreements are fair and legally sound; and
  • Easing stress and giving you confidence during discussions.

Approaching mediation with a lawyer can help you feel prepared, protected, and focused on finding solutions.

Choose Theut Scaringelli & Kupiszewski P.L.C. for Probate Mediation

If you are facing a probate conflict, mediation may be the right choice to bring clarity and peace during a difficult time. Theut Scaringelli & Kupiszewski understands that mediation is about protecting families during some of the most challenging moments of their lives.

Our attorneys have decades of combined experience handling all aspects of Arizona probate, guardianship, trust, and estate matters. We bring unmatched knowledge to both the courtroom and mediation table. Attorney Stephen Kupiszewski is a retired Maricopa County Superior Court Commissioner who presided over more than 500 probate trials and settlement conferences. He and the team draw on this experience to guide clients through mediation with compassion.

Families benefit from our collaborative approach and solution-focused strategies. Our team at Theut Scaringelli & Kupiszewski can walk you through every step of the mediation process. Contact us today to learn how we can help resolve your mediation probate disputes.